Landscape with the Fall of Icarus - Pieter Bruegel the Elder

Hi! If you're new to this newsletter here’s how it works:

Each morning I spend a few minutes searching the internet for an old painting or similar that I think looks cool (professional I know). Today it was this painting of the classic story of Icarus.

(View the full sized image here)

I then give identifying info about the work to Perplexity with the instructions to research it and tell me all the interesting things it can about said work.

The Enigmatic Fall: Exploring Bruegel's "Landscape with the Fall of Icarus"
In a sweeping Mediterranean landscape bathed in the golden light of a setting sun, a plowman diligently works his field, a shepherd gazes dreamily at the sky, and a fisherman focuses intently on his line. Meanwhile, in the bottom right corner of this idyllic scene, barely noticeable, a pair of flailing legs disappear into the sea's emerald waters. This is the dramatic yet understated depiction of mythological tragedy in "Landschap met de val van Icarus" (Landscape with the Fall of Icarus), a masterpiece attributed to—though not definitively by—the renowned Flemish Renaissance painter Pieter Bruegel the Elder.

A Tragedy Overlooked
What makes this painting so captivating is not just its artistic merit, but its philosophical stance on human suffering. While Icarus drowns—having just plummeted from the sky—life around him continues uninterrupted. The plowman doesn't look up from his furrows, the shepherd remains lost in contemplation, and the fisherman keeps his attention fixed on potential catch. Even the "expensive delicate ship" that must have witnessed "a boy falling out of the sky" simply sails calmly on toward the distant port.

The ancient Greek myth tells us of Daedalus, the master craftsman who created wings of wax and feathers for himself and his son Icarus to escape imprisonment on the island of Crete. Despite his father's warnings not to fly too close to the sun, the exhilarated youth soared higher and higher until the wax melted, sending him plunging into the sea. Yet in Bruegel's interpretation, this cautionary tale of hubris becomes a meditation on humanity's indifference to individual suffering.

Artistic Mysteries and Visual Poetry
The composition is a masterclass in perspective and depth. Using a plunging viewpoint characteristic of his style, Bruegel guides our eye through a succession of diagonal planes, creating a meandering path across the canvas. The color palette transitions masterfully from earthen browns in the foreground to verdant greens in the middle distance and finally to azure blues at the horizon, further enhancing the sense of expansive space.

The painting harbors numerous intriguing elements. A partridge perched above the fisherman references another part of Ovid's tale—when Daedalus, jealous of his nephew's talent, pushed him from a citadel, only for the goddess Pallas to transform the boy into a partridge to save him. The meticulously rendered Portuguese-style ship with its four masts demonstrates Bruegel's keen interest in naval architecture.

Perhaps most puzzling is the position of the sun—setting on the horizon rather than blazing at its zenith as the myth would require. This anomaly, possibly a later addition, has fueled debates about the painting's authorship.

A Canvas of Controversy
Oil on canvas and measuring 73.5 by 112 centimeters, this unassuming masterpiece carries a contentious history. While long attributed to Bruegel, technical examinations in 1996 cast significant doubt on this claim. Many experts now believe it to be a high-quality early copy of a lost Bruegel original from around 1558. The Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, where the painting resides, acknowledges this ambiguity: "It is doubtful the execution is by Bruegel the Elder, but the composition can be said with certainty to be his".

The painting's material history adds to its mystery. Studies haven't pinpointed its creation date more precisely than somewhere between 1555 and 1635. Due to tears and flaws, it was restretched multiple times before being acquired by the museum in 1912, complicating further analysis.

Cultural Legacy
Despite—or perhaps because of—its enigmatic nature, the painting has profoundly influenced modern literature. W.H. Auden immortalized it in his poem "Musée des Beaux-Arts" after viewing it in 1938, reflecting on how suffering "takes place while someone else is eating or opening a window or just walking dully along". William Carlos Williams similarly paid homage to the work in his own poem titled "Landscape with the Fall of Icarus".

The painting represents Bruegel's only known foray into classical mythology, a significant departure from his usual biblical subjects and peasant scenes. By relegating the mythological hero to a tiny detail while elevating ordinary laborers to prominence, Bruegel subverted the emerging hierarchy of genres in Renaissance art.

The Artist Behind the Mystery
Pieter Bruegel the Elder (c. 1525-1569) stands as one of the most significant painters of the Dutch and Flemish Renaissance. Known primarily for his landscapes and narrative scenes populated with peasants, Bruegel earned the nickname "Peasant Bruegel" for his frequent depictions of rural life. His works often reimagined biblical or mythological events, placing them in contemporary settings with similar portrayals of personal hardship alongside humanity's tendency to continue everyday life regardless of individual tragedy.

Whether "Landscape with the Fall of Icarus" flowed directly from his brush or merely from his imagination, it remains a profound meditation on human nature—one that continues to captivate viewers with its delicate balance of beauty and indifference, more than four centuries after its creation.

And that's it!

If you have any details you think Perplexity left out, reply to this email and I'll adjust my prompt to nudge it to include it next time.

This blog was part of my daily newsletter. You can subscribe to it here.

Thanks for reading!

-JP

Current prompt: I want you to create a newsletter post describing the fun and exciting stories around a painting. It should be a newsletter read for leisure and should be an enjoyable read (not just a list of facts) here's what you’re gonna do: Find the name of the following painting in its original language and any alternative names it goes by. Then Research the painting and give me blurb telling me all you can about the artist, the historical context/events it was created in, the style, the materials used, the composition and visual elements, the story/underlying message, what inspired the work/what it meant to the author, and whatever other info you find that helps give a complete understanding of the work. A description of what is depicted (mention subjects) should be the first thing, while the “biography” of the artist should be last. Besides that you are free to present the information in a concise and captivating way, with the most interesting and novel stuff closest to the top. Order the presentation of information for which pieces have the most compelling and interesting story to tell. At least some of the description should be formatted like a story. [for example: a couple sits on a bench watching the sunset while a man next to them…]. ONLY include information that is for THIS SPECIFIC PAINTING. you will find info on paintings similar to this one but NOT this one. OMMIT INFO ABOUT SUCH PIECES.