Cliffs at Étretat

Hi! If you're new to this newsletter heres how it works:

Each morning I spend a few minutes searching the internet for an old painting or similar that i think looks cool (professional i know). today it was this painting of a cliff in France from 1870:

(View the full sized image here)

I then give identifying info about the work to Perplexity with the instructions to research it and tell me all the interesting things it can about said work. today it gave me this:

Gustave Courbet's "Cliffs at Étretat": A Masterpiece of French Realism

The monumental limestone cliffs of Étretat rise dramatically from the tranquil sea, their rugged textures bearing witness to the erosive power of nature. In the foreground, several fishing boats rest on the empty beach, suggesting life slowly returning to normalcy following a turbulent storm. The imposing arch known as the Porte d'Aval stands as a natural sculpture, framing the endless expanse of ocean beyond. Above, the sky displays a splendid array of clearing clouds with patches of azure breaking through dispersing gray, conveying a profound sense of calmness and renewal. The striking interplay of light and shadow enhances the contours of the cliff face and serene sea surface, capturing the mutable character of light in this coastal Norman landscape.

The Master of Realism: Gustave Courbet

Jean Désiré Gustave Courbet, born in 1819 in Ornans, France, emerged as the leading figure of the Realism movement in 19th-century French painting. His artistic philosophy centered on painting only what he could directly observe, rejecting both the academic conventions and Romantic tendencies that dominated the art world of his time. Courbet's independence and innovative approach to painting established a precedent that would later influence artistic movements such as Impressionism and Cubism. He was not merely an artistic revolutionary but also a political one, with strong anti-monarchical sentiments that manifested in his famous refusal to accept the prestigious Cross of the Legion of Honor from Emperor Napoleon III.

The summer of 1869 found Courbet in Étretat, a small fishing village on the Normandy coast that had become increasingly popular among painters drawn by its exceptional light quality and dramatic scenery. Staying in a house nestled against the sea near the Falaise d'Aval (the cliff on the left of the bay), Courbet immersed himself in the landscape, completing five views of the cliffs and numerous seascapes during his month-long visit. Working rapidly outdoors in the plein air tradition, he captured the essence of this spectacular coastal formation with remarkable fidelity and emotional resonance.

Artistic Technique and Composition

"The Cliff at Etretat after the Storm" exemplifies Courbet's mastery of oil on canvas, measuring an impressive 133 cm by 162 cm and currently housed in the Musée d'Orsay in Paris. The composition demonstrates Courbet's artistic brilliance in balancing the powerful elements of land, rock, sky, and sea into a harmonious whole that transcends mere representation to evoke profound emotional response. What distinguishes this work is Courbet's deliberate choice to create a pure landscape devoid of human presence or anecdotal details, focusing entirely on the natural elements and their inherent grandeur.

Courbet's technical approach to this painting reveals his innovative spirit. He employed both palette knife and loaded brush to render the rugged textures of the cliff face, creating a tactile quality that contrasts beautifully with the smoother treatment of the grass-covered areas and the atmospheric sky. This textural variety enhances the painting's sense of depth and dimension while showcasing Courbet's versatility as a painter. The color palette remains faithful to nature, featuring earthy tones for the cliffs and shoreline with varying shades of blue and gray for the sea and sky, all rendered with meticulous attention to how light interacts with different surfaces.

Historical Context and Significance

The creation of "The Cliff at Etretat after the Storm" occurred during a pivotal period in French history and in Courbet's own life. The early 1870s would soon bring dramatic changes to France with the Franco-Prussian War and the Paris Commune uprising, events that would profoundly impact Courbet's life. His participation in the Paris Commune—particularly his involvement in the dismantling of the Vendôme Column—would lead to his imprisonment for six months in 1871 and his subsequent exile to Switzerland, where he remained until his death in 1877.

Courbet sent both "The Etretat Cliffs after the Storm" and "The Wave" to the Salon of 1870, where they received substantial critical acclaim. The celebrated critic Castagnary, a friend of Courbet's and advocate for realism, particularly praised the painting for "the free, joyous air which circulates in the canvas and envelops the details." This recognition solidified Courbet's position as one of the leading artists of his time and validated his revolutionary approach to landscape painting.

The Painting's Legacy and Influence

What makes "The Cliff at Etretat after the Storm" especially significant in art history is its position at a crucial artistic crossroads. While firmly rooted in the realist tradition, the painting's emphasis on the emotional impact of light and atmospheric conditions, along with Courbet's increasingly abstract approach to natural forms, foreshadowed the Impressionist movement that would soon transform the art world. Indeed, the future Impressionists expressed great admiration for Courbet's handling of light and his artistic freedom, seeing in his work a path forward for their own explorations.

In his treatment of the Étretat cliffs, Courbet eliminated references to the village and tourist elements that others might have included, focusing instead on the elemental relationship between rock, water, and sky. This approach revealed his ability to see beyond the picturesque aspects of a site to its fundamental essence. As Courbet himself articulated his artistic philosophy: "Painting is an art of sight and should therefore concern itself with things seen; it should, therefore, abandon both historical scenes and poetic subjects."

Courbet's Personal Connection to the Landscape

Courbet's deep connection to the landscape of Étretat is evident in the emotional resonance of "The Cliff at Etretat after the Storm." During his stay in the summer of 1869, he wrote enthusiastically to his family about the dramatic rock formations, describing them as "tremendous." This genuine excitement reflects Courbet's lifelong affinity for natural settings, cultivated during his childhood in the rocky terrain of eastern France near Ornans, where he frequently returned throughout his life to hunt, fish, and find inspiration.

The painting represents more than just a scenic view; it embodies Courbet's belief that truth in art emerges from direct observation and emotional engagement with the subject. The cliffs of Étretat, with their imposing presence and natural grandeur, provided him with the perfect motif to explore these artistic principles. In rendering the clarity of the air and the limpid light following the rain, Courbet created what many consider the most accomplished version of his Étretat cliff paintings, a work that manages to make each natural element almost palpably real while still conveying their collective emotional impact.

Conclusion

"The Cliff at Etretat after the Storm" stands as a testament to Gustave Courbet's revolutionary approach to landscape painting and his profound influence on subsequent generations of artists. Through its masterful balance of realism and emotional resonance, technical innovation and compositional harmony, the painting captures not just the visual appearance of the Normandy coast but its essential character. In choosing to focus on the raw power and beauty of nature rather than human drama or picturesque elements, Courbet created a work that speaks across time, inviting viewers to experience the same awe and wonder that he felt standing before these magnificent cliffs over 150 years ago.

In this singular work, we see not only Courbet's mastery as a painter but his radical vision of what art could be—a vision that would help transform the course of Western art and that continues to resonate with viewers today. The painting's enduring power lies in its ability to transport us to that moment after the storm at Étretat, where we can almost feel the fresh sea breeze and hear the gentle lapping of waves against the shore, experiencing through Courbet's eyes the sublime beauty of this remarkable landscape.

And that's it!

If you have any details you think Perplexity left out, reply to this email and I'll adjust my prompt to nudge it to include it next time.

this blog was part of my daily newsletter. you can subscribe to it here.

Thanks for reading!

-JP

Current prompt: Research the following painting and give me blurb telling me all you can about the artist, the historical context/events it was created in, the style, the materials used, the composition and visual elements, the story/underlying message, what inspired the work/what it meant to the author, and whatever other info you find that helps give a complete understanding of the work. Order the presentation of information for which pieces have the most compelling and interesting story to tell. A description of what is depicted (mention subjects) should be the first thing included but after that you are free to present the information in a concise and captivating way. At least some of the description should be formatted like a story. [fore example: a couple sits on a bench watching the sunset while a man next to them…]. ONLY include information that is for THIS SPECIFIC PAINTING. you will find info on paintings similar to this one but NOT this one. OMMIT INFO ABOUT SUCH PIECES.